[Bitcoin-development] Draft BIP for seamless website authentication using Bitcoin address

Mike Hearn mike at plan99.net
Fri Apr 4 13:54:52 UTC 2014


>
> What if I do a shared spend/CoinJoin type tx? Now anyone who took part in
> the shared tx with me can get into my hotel room too?
>

Oh, if these seem too abstract, also consider bitbanks. In an ideal world
nobody would outsource running of their Bitcoin wallet, but sadly people
do, so then they don't control the private keys at all.

The goal of writing a BIP seems to be to get lots of different wallet
authors to write lots of code for you - but I *am* a wallet author, and I
don't think that's the right way to get traction with a new scheme. For
instance the TREZOR guys would have to support your new protocol otherwise
if I paid my hotel bill with my TREZOR I couldn't open the door when I got
there! But they probably have better things to be doing right now.

The key difference between just generating a client certificate and using a
Bitcoin address is that the client certificate is something that is used
*specifically* for identification. It leaves no trace in the block chain,
so no weird privacy issues, it doesn't matter how you manage your wallet,
and you don't have to persuade lots of people to support your idea because
it was already done >10 years ago and basically every browser/web server
supports it.

Some reasons client certs aren't more widely used boil down to:

   1. People like passwords. In particular they like forgetting them and
   then having friendly people assist them to get it back. Client certs can
   support this use case, but only if apps are checking the identity in them
   and not the key.
   2. The UI for managing client certs in browsers is pretty horrible.
   There's little incentive to improve it because of (1).
   3. Cross-device sync doesn't work very well. Apple are starting to
   tackle this with their iCloud Keychain Sync service but then of course,
   Apple has all your keys and you may well just sign in to things with your
   Apple account (if it were to be supported). Cross-device sync where the
   server *doesn't* get your keys is supported by Chrome for passwords, but
   not client certs, because (1)

None of the above issues have any obvious fix lurking within Bitcoin.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/attachments/20140404/bbeaf3b0/attachment.html>


More information about the bitcoin-dev mailing list