[cgl_discussion] FYI - PoC Tracking Sheets updated

Steven Dake sdake at mvista.com
Tue Jun 17 08:21:46 PDT 2003


Julie & Rusty,

Great job on the tracking sheets folks!

I would suggest one change, which is that we need to add TimeSys to the 
list of targets. To enable this change, would it make sense to move 
Category to the top of each section (eg: category carryover, then list 
all of the carryover requirements)? This would give more room for adding 
this field without squeezing other fields.

Thanks
-steve

Fleischer, Julie N wrote:

>Just thought you might like to know that I have updated the PoC tracking sheet on the web with the best data I have so far.  The only area where there are blanks is in the "carryover, unchanged" requirements.  This should be a simple port from Andy's spreadsheet when we get the time.
>
>The file names are:
>XLS format - http://www.osdl.org/docs/poc_cgl_20_priority_1_solutions.xls
>PDF format - http://www.osdl.org/docs/cgl_20_p1_project_list___pdf_format.pdf
>HTML format - attached
>
>- Julie
>
>**These views are not necessarily those of my employer.**
>  
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> CGL 2.0 Req. 	Category 	License 	Project 	Status 	Gap Analysis 	MV 
> Target 	Suse Target 	RH Target
> Linux Standard Base Compliance 	CARRYOVER 	N/A 	Linux Standard Base 
> (http://www.linuxbase.org/) 	Use Linux kernel. 	On a per-distro 
> basis. 	Assume so 	Assume so 	Assume so
> POSIX Core Functionality 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	2.4 and 2.5 kernel 	Stable. 
> There will always be various bugs in the kernel, but choosing a modern 
> 2.4 or 2.6 kernel meets 100% of this requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 
> Unknown
> Bariers 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NPTL (Active development on LKML); POSIX Test 
> Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	Supported in at least 
> version 0.43 of the NPTL library 	There is no question that NPTL 
> implementes exactly what this requirement is asking for. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Message Passing 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	Wronski/Benedyczak - 
> http://www-users.mat.uni.torun.pl/~wrona/posix_ipc/. ; POSIX Test 
> Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	Developer releases 	Looks 
> close to full POSIX requirements. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Message Passing 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	Waetchler 
> (http://homepage.mac.com/pwaechtler/linux/mqueue.tgz); POSIX Test 
> Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	Developer releases 
> Unknown. Believed to implement close to full POSIX requirements. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Semaphores 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NPTL (Active development on LKML); POSIX Test 
> Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	Supported in at least 
> version 0.43 of the NPTL library 	There is no question that NPTL 
> implementes exactly what this requirement is asking for. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Spin Locks 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NPTL (Active development on LKML); POSIX Test 
> Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	Supported in at least 
> version 0.43 of the NPTL library 	There is no question that NPTL 
> implementes exactly what this requirement is asking for. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Threads 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NPTL (Active development on LKML); POSIX Test 
> Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	Supported in at least 
> version 0.43 of the NPTL library 	There is no question that NPTL 
> implementes exactly what this requirement is asking for. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Timers (TMR, Clock Selection, Monotonic Clock) 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	Linux 
> Kernel 2.5.65 plus HRT user space (http://high-res-timers.sf.net); 
> POSIX Test Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	Stable (may 
> have a few bugs to work out). 	Implements POSIX requirements. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Timeouts 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NPTL (Active development on LKML); POSIX Test 
> Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	Supported in at least 
> version 0.43 of the NPTL library 	There is no question that NPTL 
> implementes exactly what this requirement is asking for. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> POSIX Synchronization and Scheduling Support 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	Linux 
> Kernel; POSIX Test Suite (http://posixtest.sf.net) for testing 	In 
> Linux Kernel. 	Need to test, but believed to fully implement 
> requirement. 	N/A 	N/A 	N/A
> Persistent Device Naming 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	Hot Device Identity 
> (http://sourceforge.net/projects/hdi/) 	No stable release yet. 
> Website says it implements full requirement. Unsure that it meets the 
> spirit of the requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Persistent Device Naming 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	Udev 
> (http://www.ussg.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/0304.1/0753.html.) 
> Appears just in development releases. 	I believe implements 
> requirement, but only works for block and usb-serial devices. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Persistent Device Naming 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	MontaVista Linux udev tool 
> Not released yet. 	May implement more pieces of requirement. 	Assume 
> so 	Unknown 	Unknown
> IPMI 1.5 	SYSTEM 	GPL, LGPL 	Linux 2.5 kernel + Open IMPI 
> (http://sourceforge.net/projects/openipmi/) 	Linux kernel OK. OpenIPMI 
> still in development and has bugs. 	Meets requirements. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Service Availability Forum Hardware Platform Interface (HPI) 
> SYSTEM 	BSD 	OpenHPI (http://openhpi.sf.net) 	Project is currently on 
> track for production ready release in mid-2004 	This project will (by 
> mid-2004) meet 100% of the CGL requirement. More resources could be 
> applied in order to push the production release date up. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Robust Mutexes 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NPTL (Active development on LKML) 	NPTL 
> patch being worked on by Inaky. If this featue is to be accepted into 
> NPTL, then user demand needs to be made more visible. 	This patch was 
> created specifically with the CGL robust mutexes requirement in 
> mind. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Software ECC Support 	SYSTEM 	LGPL 	RSCode 
> (http://rscode.sourceforge.net/) 	Appears stable, but not active. 
> Code appears to implement requirement. Maybe intent was to move this 
> into the kernel? 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Software Remote Update and Installation 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	System 
> Installation Suite (http://sisuite.sf.net) 	Appears stable and has 
> fairly recent releases. 	SIS implements this feature. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Software Remote Update and Installation 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	RedHat - 
> Kickstart 
> (http://www.redhat.com/docs/manuals/linux/RHL-7.3-Manual/custom-guide/ch-kickstart2.html) 
> 	Appears stable. 	Has some pieces of requirement, but it's for RH 
> installations. 	N/A 	N/A 	Ships with
> Software Remote Update and Installation 	CARRYOVER 	Special 	SuSE - 
> YaST 
> (http://www.suse.de/en/whitepapers/yast/Auto_Install_English_text.txt) 
> Appears stable. 	Has some pieces of requirement, but it's for SuSE 
> installations. 	N/A 	Ships with 	N/A
> Software Live Upgrade Minimal Reboot 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	Linux kernel 
> Stable. 	Requirements doc states already available. 	Done 	Done 	Done
> Software Live Upgrade RPM Version Check 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	System 
> Installation Suite (http://sisuite.sf.net) 	Appears stable and has 
> fairly recent releases. 	This may be a goal of this product 
> eventually. Difficult to tell for sure. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Software Live Upgrade RPM Version Check 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	RedHat - 
> Kickstart 
> (http://www.redhat.com/docs/manuals/linux/RHL-7.3-Manual/custom-guide/ch-kickstart2.html) 
> 	Appears stable. 	Not sure that this is designed to meet this 
> requirement. 	N/A 	N/A 	Ships with
> Software Live Upgrade RPM Version Check 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	SuSE - YaST 
> (http://www.suse.de/en/whitepapers/yast/Auto_Install_English_text.txt) 
> Appears stable. 	Not sure that this is designed to meet this 
> requirement. 	N/A 	Ships with 	N/A
> Software Live Upgrade Log 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	System Installation Suite 
> (http://sisuite.sf.net) 	Appears stable and has fairly recent 
> releases. 	Probably does some of this. Not sure about all. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Software Live Upgrade Log 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	RedHat - Kickstart 
> (http://www.redhat.com/docs/manuals/linux/RHL-7.3-Manual/custom-guide/ch-kickstart2.html) 
> 	Appears stable. 	Probably does some of this. Not sure about all. 
> N/A 	N/A 	Ships with
> Software Live Upgrade Log 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	SuSE - YaST 
> (http://www.suse.de/en/whitepapers/yast/Auto_Install_English_text.txt) 
> Appears stable. 	Probably does some of this. Not sure about all. 
> N/A 	Ships with 	N/A
> Forced Unmount 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	MontaVista Linux 
> (http://www.mvista.com/tech3.html) 	Appears stable. May need work to 
> get into Linux kernel. 	Appears to implement full requirement. 
> Assume so 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Forced Unmount 	CARRYOVER 	Open, but needs maintenance agreement? 
> Veritas (TBD - http://www.veritas.com/van/products/nfsmount.html?) 
> Appears stable. 	Appears to implement full requirement. 	N/A 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Linux Panic Handler Enhancements 	CARRYOVER 	BSD 	Panic Handler 
> Enhancements (http://panicsel.sf.net) 	Appears stable, but this 
> functionality is all in the IMPI driver in the 2.5 kernel. 	Appears 
> that requirement was written with this in mind. Appears to implement 
> full requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Linux Panic Handler Enhancements 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	kksymoops 
> (http://lwn.net/Articles/10796/) 	Tough to tell. Doesn't have it's own 
> website. 	Doesn't appear to implement requirement. Just gives 
> additional log detail. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Linux Panic Handler Enhancements 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	Linux 2.5 Kernel 
> Stable. 	Implements full requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> SNMP for IPv4 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NetSNMP (http://www.netsnmp.org) 	TBD 
> When finished, NetSNMP should meet this requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> SNMP IPv6 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NetSNMP (http://www.netsnmp.org) 	Still being 
> worked on. 	When finished, NetSNMP should meet this requirement. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> SNMP Baseline MIBS 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NetSNMP (http://www.netsnmp.org) 
> TBD 	When finished, NetSNMP should meet this requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> SNMP IPv6 MIBS 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	NetSNMP (http://www.netsnmp.org) 	Only 
> very limited set of objects work in the current NetSNMP 
> implementation. Finishing this feature is gated by finishing kernel 
> support. 	When finished, NetSNMP should meet this requirement. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> SNMP IPv6 Kernel Interface - Get 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	Randy Dunlap's patches 
> on LKML. 	In development. Active. 	Randy's kernel patch is being 
> written to meet this requirement 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> SVR4-compatible STREAMS driver 	SYSTEM 	GPLL, GPL 	Linux STREAMS 
> (http://www.gcom.com/home/linux/lis/) 	Stable 	Implements 
> requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Realtime Support Performance 	CARRYOVER 	?? 	?? 	?? 	?? 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Managing Transient Data 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	/tmpfs in Linux Kernel 
> Stable 	Implements requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Managing Transient Data 	CARRYOVER 	GPL 	RAMFS 
> (http://www.linuxhq.com/kernel/file/fs/ramfs/) 	Stable 	Implements 
> requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Low-Level Asynchronous Events 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	AEM 
> (http://www.linux.ericsson.ca/aem/) 	Project currently has a 2.4.19 
> kernel patch, and needs a 2.5 port. There is also some consern that 
> the implementation of the patch will need some major rewrite if it is 
> to be accepted into the kernel. 	Since the original requirement was 
> written with AEM functionality in mind, there is little doubt that AEM 
> provides 100% of what the requirement calls for. 	Unknown 	Unknown 
> Unknown
> Low-Level Asynchronous Events 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	epoll kernel patch on 
> LKML 	In development. Active. 	Not meant to fully implement 
> requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Low-Level Asynchronous Events 	SYSTEM 	GPL 	Async I/O capabilies in 
> current 2.5 kernel 	Stable. 	Not full requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 
> Unknown
> IPv6, IPSECv6, MIPv6 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look 
> at shipped 	Look at shipped
> IPSECv6 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at shipped 
> Look at shipped
> MIPv6 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at shipped 
> Look at shipped
> Stream Control Transport Protocol (SCTP) 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 				 
> Look at shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Hot Plug Insertion 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped
> Hot Plug Deletion 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped
> Remote Boot Support 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look 
> at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Boot Cycle Detection 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look 
> at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Loading Proprietary Modules 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Diskless Systems 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped
> Serial Console Connection 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 
> Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Watchdog Timer Interface Requirements 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look 
> at shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Application Heartbeat Monitor 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Ethernet Link Aggregation 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 
> Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Ethernet Link Failover 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 
> Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> RAID 1 Support 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped
> Resilient Filesystem Support 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Disk and Volume Management 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Kernel Message Structuring 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Dynamic Debug / Probe Insertion 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Platform Signal Handler 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 
> Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Remote Access to Event Log 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> User-Level (gdb) Debug Support for Threads 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 				 
> Look at shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Kernel Debugger 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped
> Soft Real-Time Performance 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Kernel Pre-emption 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped
> RAID 0 Support 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look at 
> shipped 	Look at shipped
> Application Loading 	CARRYOVER, unchanged 					Look at shipped 	Look 
> at shipped 	Look at shipped
> Cluster Node Failure Detection 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 	TIPC 
> (http://tipc.sf.net) 	In development. Active. 	When finished, should 
> implement full requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Cluster Node Failure Detection 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 	Linux-HA Heartbeat 
> (http://www.linux-ha.org) 	Stable. 	May need a wrapper to implement 
> full requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Cluster Node Failure Detection 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 	SGI Linux Failsafe 
> (http://www.sgi.com/software/failsafe/) 	Stable. 	Implements some of 
> the spirit of the requirement. May not implement full requirement. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Cluster Node Failure Detection 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 	Mission Critical 
> Kimberlite Project 
> (http://oss.missioncriticallinux.com/projects/kimberlite/) 	Stable. 
> Implements some of the spirit of the requirement. May not implement 
> full requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Cluster Communication Service – Logical Addressing 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 
> Linux-HA Heartbeat (http://www.linux-ha.org) 	Stable. 	May need some 
> additional features added to implement full requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Cluster Communication Service – Logical Addressing 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 
> TIPC (http://tipc.sf.net) 	In development. Active. 	When finished, 
> should implement full requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Cluster Communication Service – Fault Handling 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 
> Linux-HA Heartbeat (http://www.linux-ha.org) 	Stable 	May need some 
> additional features added to implement full requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Cluster Communication Service – Fault Handling 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 	TIPC 
> (http://tipc.sf.net) 	In development. Active. 	When finished, should 
> implement full requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> NFS Server Failover 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 	Mission Critical Kimberlite 
> Project (http://oss.missioncriticallinux.com/projects/kimberlite/) 
> Stable. 	Implements requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Multi-Path Access to Storage 	CLUSTERING 	GPL 	IBM project for 
> mid-layer SCSI multipath driver 	In development. Active. 	TBD 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Password Integrity Checking 	SECURITY 	BSD and other OS licenses 
> pam_passwdc PAM module (http://www.openwall.com/passwdqc) 	Only has 
> development releases. 	Appears to meet requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Password Integrity Checking 	SECURITY 	OS license 	pam_cracklib PAM 
> module (http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/libs/pam/) 	Already in 
> distros. 	Appears to meet requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Password Integrity Checking 	SECURITY 	Not sure -- May not be OS 	John 
> the Ripper (http://www.openwall.com/john/) 	Stable. 	Meets 
> requirements. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Password Integrity Checking 	SECURITY 	Artistic License 	Crack 
> (ftp://ftp.cerias.purdue.edu/pub/tools/unix/pwdutils/crack) 	Stable. 
> I have read performance may be slow. This may need to be tested to see 
> if it fulfills requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Generic Kernel Security Modules 	SECURITY 	GPL 	Linux Security 
> Modules: http://lsm.immunix.org/ 	LSM implements this requirement and 
> is already in Linux 2.5 kernel. Not sure if all features are in 2.5, 
> but, currently, it appears no CGL work is needed. 	Requirement was 
> written exactly for this project in it's current state, so there is no 
> doubt that LSM meets 100% of this requirment 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> IPSec for IPv4 	SECURITY 	GPL 	Linux >=2.5.49 plus user-space packages 
> from http://sourceforge.net/projects/ipsec-tools 	In kernel, stable. 
> User space packages, in active development. Also, user space needs to 
> be integrated in with kernel. 	Implements requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> IPSec for IPv4 	SECURITY 	GPL - Legal issues on use 
> http://www.freeswan.org/ 	Only for 2.4 kernels. 	Implements 
> requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Support for IKE 	SECURITY 	GPL 	Linux >=2.5.49 plus user-space 
> packages from http://sourceforge.net/projects/ipsec-tools 	In kernel, 
> stable. User space packages, in active development. Also, user space 
> needs to be integrated in with kernel. 	Implements requirement. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Support for IKE 	SECURITY 	GPL - Legal issues on use 
> http://www.freeswan.org/ 	Only for 2.4 kernels. 	Implements 
> requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> PF_KEY support 	SECURITY 	GPL 	Linux >=2.5.49 plus user-space packages 
> from http://sourceforge.net/projects/ipsec-tools 	In kernel, stable. 
> User space packages, in active development. Also, user space needs to 
> be integrated in with kernel. 	Implements requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> PF_KEY support 	SECURITY 	GPL - Legal issues on use 
> http://www.freeswan.org/ 	Only for 2.4 kernels. 	Implements 
> requirement. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> PKI CA Support 	SECURITY 	Apache-style 	OpenCA 
> (http://www.openca.org) 	Has a development release only. Work would be 
> needed to get it to 1.0. TBD if there are other 
> performance/functionality issues too. 	Not sure that it meets full 
> requirements based on looking at the project's TODO list. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> PKI CA Support 	SECURITY 	GPL 	pyCA (http://www.pyca.de) 	Has a 
> development release only. Work would be needed to get it to 1.0. TBD 
> if there are other performance/functionality issues too. Project 
> doesn't appear to be active currently. 	May meet full requirements. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Secure integrity check at user-level 	SECURITY 	GPL 	Tripwire 
> (http://www.tripwire.org) 	Has stable open source release. 	Meets full 
> requirements. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Secure integrity check at user-level 	SECURITY 	GPL 	RPM 
> (http://www.rpm.org/) 	Has stable releases. 	Doesn't check files which 
> change. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Secure integrity check at user-level 	SECURITY 	GPL 	AIDE 
> (http://www.cs.tut.fi/~rammer/aide.html) 	Does not have a development 
> release yet. 	Website says it does what Tripwire does; therefore, 
> should meet full requirements. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Secure integrity check at user-level 	SECURITY 	TBD 	Bsigns 
> (http://packages.debian.org/testing/admin/bsign.html) 	Does not have a 
> development release yet. 	Embeds hashes into all files. Doesn't appear 
> to meet requirements as does not check text files. 	Unknown 	Unknown 
> Unknown
> Support for encrypted file systems 	SECURITY 	GPL 	Loop-AES 
> (http://loop-aes.sourceforge.net) 	Project appears stable. 	Only does 
> AES cipher. Doesn't seem to meet spirit of requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Support for encrypted file systems 	SECURITY 	GPL 	StegFS 
> (http://mcdonald.org.uk/StegFS/) 	Doesn't work on 2.4.X kernels. Only 
> in development releases. 	Appears to meet requirement. Have validation 
> notes that it may have performance issues. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Support for encrypted file systems 	SECURITY 	GPL 	ReiserFS 
> (http://www.namesys.com/ ) 	Currently experimental for 2.5. Should be 
> production end of June 03. 	Appears to meet requirement. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Support for encrypted file systems 	SECURITY 	N/A 	Encrytpion HOWTO 
> -includes patches to losetup and mount 
> (http://encryptionhowto.sourceforge.net/Encryption-HOWTO-4.html, 
> section 4.3) 	Need permission to use ciphers. Need patches on version 
> of losetup and mount in distro. 	Appears to meet requirement. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Logs integrity and origin authentication of logs 	SECURITY 	BSD 	SDSC 
> (http://security.sdsc.edu/software/sdsc-syslog/) 	Just had stable 
> release. 	Appears to meet requirement. TBD if there are performance 
> issues or bugs in functionality. CGL may want to test these items. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Logs integrity and origin authentication of logs 	SECURITY 	GPL 
> Secure Audit Project (http://secureaudit.sourceforge.net/) 	Had a 
> stable release 2/19/03 	Appears to meet requirement. TBD if there are 
> performance issues or bugs in functionality. CGL may want to test 
> these items. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Logs integrity and origin authentication of logs 	SECURITY 	BSD 
> msyslog (http://sourceforge.net/projects/msyslog/) 	Just had stable 
> release. 	Appears to meet requirement. TBD if there are performance 
> issues or bugs in functionality. CGL may want to test these items. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Confidentiality of log information 	SECURITY 	BSD 	SDSC 
> (http://security.sdsc.edu/software/sdsc-syslog/) 	Just had stable 
> release. 	Appears to meet requirement. TBD if there are performance 
> issues or bugs in functionality. CGL may want to test these items. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Confidentiality of log information 	SECURITY 	GPL 	Secure Audit 
> Project (http://secureaudit.sourceforge.net/) 	Had a stable release 
> 2/19/03 	Appears to meet requirement. TBD if there are performance 
> issues or bugs in functionality. CGL may want to test these items. 
> Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Confidentiality of log information 	SECURITY 	BSD 	syslog-ng 
> (http://www.balabit.com/products/syslog_ng/) 	Appears stable. 	Appears 
> to meet requirement. TBD if there are performance issues or bugs in 
> functionality. CGL may want to test these items. 	Unknown 	Unknown 
> Unknown
> Support for automated log analysis 	SECURITY 	GPL 	Swatch 
> (http://sourceforge.net/projects/swatch) 	Appears quite stable. 
> Appears to meet requirement. TBD if there are performance issues or 
> bugs in functionality. CGL may want to test these items. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Support for automated log analysis 	SECURITY 	No name 	LogWatch 
> (http://www.logwatch.org) 	Appears quite stable. 	Does not meet 
> requirement. Does not have alarms capability. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> Support for automated log analysis 	SECURITY 	No name 	LogDog 
> (http://caspian.dotconf.net/menu/Software/LogDog/) 	Appears stable. 
> Appears to meet requirement. TBD if there are performance issues or 
> bugs in functionality. CGL may want to test these items. 	Unknown 
> Unknown 	Unknown
> Support for automated log analysis 	SECURITY 	GPL 	My-swatch 
> (http://caspian.dotconf.net/menu/Software/LogDog/) 	Only has 
> development releases. 	Appears to meet requirement. TBD if there are 
> performance issues or bugs in functionality. CGL may want to test 
> these items. 	Unknown 	Unknown 	Unknown
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
> 								
>
> 	
> 	
> 	
> 	
> 	
> 	
> 	
> 	
>




More information about the cgl_discussion mailing list