robert.schweikert at mathworks.com
Fri Feb 1 11:34:02 PST 2008
Theodore Tso wrote:
> On Fri, Feb 01, 2008 at 12:02:50PM -0500, Robert Schweikert wrote:
>> For this use case we need to further explore the "plugin certification
>> model" we have kicked around. Basically the vendors makes the statement
>> that says "Certified with any LSB compliant JRE". How we will test this
>> type of app needs to be determined, not sure whether or not Jeff had a
>> proposal for this.
> Yeah... I'm a little concerned about this. The devil will be in the
> details. It's certain the we will need to be very careful about what
> we allow to be specified in this way to avoid abuse. Otherwise people
> could start saying things like "Certified with any LSB compliant
> <FOO>", where FOO could be anything from "Microsoft .Net runtime", or
> "Infocomm Z-code interpreter" to "Oracle Database".
> I assume here that we would get to decide what sort of "Certified with
> any LSB compliant <FOO>" could be used, and we would get to set the
> rules; but there still is the unfortunate situation where it
> effectively means that there is an asterisk on the certification, and
> so someone who purchases a software package might not get something
> that works out of the box. The confusion is not too different from
> what happens if we start having profiles, which is another issue that
> we will need to figure out.
Agreed, this certainly falls into the profile discussion. My thinking is
that no one can say "Certified with LSB compliant <FOO>" if we do not
have a <FOO> profile.
>> In this case the ISV can put pressure on the JRE provider to get the JRE
> They could, but that presumes the ISV cares enough, and that the ISV
> can put enough pressure on a JRE provider that the JRE provider would
> pay attention to the ISV.
Yes, but we make the assumptions that ISVs care enough to get certified
anyway. If we don't make that assumption we're just spinning our wheels.
>> Well, all of the enterprise distro's are shipping with some JRE these
>> days. And if there is a full open source JRE which can be certified,
>> then that should be sufficient for the community distro's like Debian.
Sounds good to me.
<snip - Moved to new thread>
Robert Schweikert MAY THE SOURCE BE WITH YOU
(robert.schweikert at mathworks.com) LINUX
The MathWorks Inc.
Phone : 508-647-2042
More information about the lsb-discuss